ISA Interchange

Welcome to the official blog of the International Society of Automation (ISA).

All Posts

TUNE YOUR LOOP: Advanced Design and Safety Instrumented Level (SIL) Verification

TUNE YOUR LOOP:  Questions to keep you sharp.

 

 

1. How should a redundant system respond upon detection of a dangerous fault?

  1. Fail dangerously
  2. Shut down safely
  3. Continue operating with no time limit
  4. Continue operating as long as the fault is repaired within a specified time

2. The standard allows testing of systems either end-to-end or in parts. What are the pros and cons of testing in parts?

 

What are your answers before you read ahead?

1. How should a redundant system respond upon detection of a dangerous fault?

d. Continue operating as long as the fault is repaired within a specified time

 2. The standard allows testing of systems either end-to-end or in parts. What are the pros and cons of testing in parts?

Testing in parts is acceptable because different devices have different failure rates, failure modes and levels of diagnostics, therefore their performance varies widely. Less reliable and safe devices need to be tested more often. More reliable devices do not need to be tested as often (as long as the target performance is maintained), thereby saving money.

The drawback of testing in parts is that some interfaces might not get tested. There have been cases of individual devices all working when tested, but not working as a complete system.

From the ISA course EC54 Advanced Design and SIL Verification pre-instructional survey.


Related Posts

Coding for Automation Projects Is More Than Writing Code

Translating mathematical equations into code is part of, but also removed from, the development of automa...
Ed Farmer Sep 22, 2020 5:00:00 AM

Advancing Technology in the New Work Scenario

Technological developments have steadily changed the work scenario since the First Industrial Revolution....
Contributing Author Sep 18, 2020 5:00:00 AM

ISA President's Column: Coach, Share, Learn, and Grow

Working Together to Strengthen ISA for Our Members The International Society of Automation (ISA) Presiden...
ISA President Sep 15, 2020 5:30:00 AM