ISA Interchange

HMI Design: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly

Written by Paul Gruhn | Jun 30, 2011 10:04:02 PM

 

Poor HMI designs have been identified as factors contributing to abnormal situations, billions of dollars of lost production, accidents, and fatalities. Many HMIs actually impede rather than assist operators. Many of the poor designs are holdovers due to the limitations of early control systems and the lack of knowledge of system designers. However, with the advent of newer and more powerful systems, these limitations no longer apply.

Also, decades of research has identified better implementation methods. Unfortunately, change is difficult and people continue to follow poor design practices. In fact, some new designs are actually worse than older designs! Just as a computer is not a typewriter, new HMI designs should not mimic those of old. The problem is that many designers often simply don’t know any better. This article will review why certain HMI designs are poor (with many examples) and show how they can be improved.

Free Article Bonus: To read the full article on HMI design, click here.